When a family stone changes hands
An exceptional sapphire, ruby, emerald or coloured diamond is often the most valuable object a family owns, and the one it knows least about. Whether it is sold or bought, the route matters as much as the stone.
This article is general information, not legal, tax or investment advice. It does not take your personal situation into account. Please consult a qualified adviser before acting.
A decision families rarely plan for
Many families hold one or two stones of real importance: a Burmese ruby bought by a grandparent, a Kashmir sapphire set in a necklace that has not been worn for decades, a coloured diamond kept in a safe since it was inherited. They are rarely insured at their true value, seldom shown to a specialist, and almost never part of the conversation about the family’s wealth.
Then something changes. An estate has to be divided, and a single stone cannot be split between three children. Heirs live in different countries and have no wish to keep a piece they will never wear. Or the family simply decides that a part of its heritage would be better turned into liquidity, or passed on in another form. At that point, a stone worth well over a million dollars has to be sold by people who have never sold one.
Related reading “Family wealth changes hands twice. The first handover is the one families prepare least.” The first inheritance usually goes to a spouse →A market of very few buyers
At the top of the market, the number of serious buyers for a given stone can be counted on two hands: the great jewellery houses, a small circle of specialist dealers who supply them, and a handful of private collectors. Prices are set privately, by people who see the finest stones every week. A family that sees one in a generation starts at a disadvantage.
Source: Sotheby’s and Christie’s published auction results, prices including buyer’s premium. Shown to illustrate the top of the market; they do not indicate the value of any other stone.
Records like these make headlines, but they are the exception. Most important stones change hands privately, and quietly.
What sets the price
Two stones that look alike to a family can differ in value many times over. What the trade looks at first is on paper:
- Origin
- A sapphire from Kashmir, a ruby from Burma or an emerald from Colombia commands a premium that no other source can match.
- Treatment
- Most coloured stones have been heated or oiled to improve them. An untreated stone of the same size and colour can be worth several times more.
- Certificates
- Origin and treatment are established by laboratory reports, and the trade relies on a few houses, several of them in Switzerland. A report written decades ago may need to be renewed before a sale.
- Provenance
- A documented history, a royal or celebrated previous owner, or an original signed setting can add a great deal, and is easily lost if a piece is broken up without thought.
Three routes to a sale
Public auction. Geneva holds the major jewellery sales each spring and autumn. Auction gives visibility and a transparent result, but fees are significant, the timetable is fixed, and a stone that fails to sell is publicly known to have failed, which can weigh on its value for years.
Private sale to a jewellery house. The great houses buy exceptional stones for their high jewellery collections. It is discreet and can be quick, but each house buys for its own needs, and a family that approaches only one has no way of knowing whether the offer is fair.
Through a specialist dealer. A small number of dealers supply those houses and know, at any moment, who is looking for what. The best of them act on both sides of the market, and can place a stone with the right buyer without it ever being shown in public.
There is no single right answer. The best route depends on the stone, on how quickly the family needs to act, and on how much it values discretion.
Buying is the same question, the other way round
Families also buy: to mark an occasion, to hold a small part of their wealth in a portable and private form, or to complete a collection. The same disciplines apply. An independent opinion on the price, a recent certificate from a recognised laboratory, a clear record of where the stone has been, and checks on sanctions and origin rules, which have tightened considerably in recent years.
Where we help
We do not trade stones. Our role is to sit on the family’s side of the table. We arrange an independent valuation and up-to-date certificates, compare the routes to a sale, and introduce the family to specialists we know and trust, including dealers who supply the leading jewellery houses and buy as well as sell. We then make sure that what happens next, from the division of the estate to the investment of the proceeds, fits the family’s wider plans.
A family stone is often sold once in a generation. It deserves the same care as any other part of the family’s wealth.
This article is provided for information purposes only. It does not constitute an offer or a solicitation to buy or sell any gemstone or other asset, nor investment, tax or legal advice. Auction results are cited from public sources and are believed to be reliable but have not been independently verified by GYRA SA. The views expressed are those of the author and of GYRA SA at the date of publication and may change without notice. GYRA SA does not provide legal or tax advice; please consult a qualified adviser for your own situation.